WebJun 26, 2015 · In this case, the state trial judge seemed to conclude no such right existed, at least in public, saying, If you’re in public with your kids, it’s not appropriate to discipline … WebIn Commonwealth v. Dorvil, 472 Mass. 1, 2, 12 (2015) (Dorvil), the Supreme Judicial Court expressly recognized a common-law parental privilege to use reasonable force to discipline a minor child. The court laid out the contours of such a defense as follows:
DOBSON, COMMONWEALTH vs., 92 Mass. App. Ct. 355
WebOct 1, 2024 · The SJC ruling stems from Commonwealth vs. Dorvil, a 2011 case involving a Brockton, Massachusetts father who according to police, kicked his daughter in her backside while yelling “shut up” and then spanked her. The child was upset and crying when the police officers questioned the parents. http://masscases.com/cases/sjc/472/472mass1.html credit for other dependents 2022 refundable
Parents have a right to reasonably spank their children, says ...
WebMar 13, 2024 · Commonwealth v. Dwyer, 448 Mass. 122, 140-141 (2006), quoting Commonwealth v. Lampron, 441 Mass. 265, 269 (2004). The defendant must satisfy the rule in its entirety "before any documents of any kind may be summonsed from any third party prior to trial." Dwyer, supra at 140. We review the motion judge's decision regarding … WebMay 1, 2014 · Commonwealth v. Daley, 66 Mass. App. Ct. 254, 256 (2006). In her closing argument, the prosecutor stated that (1) defendant spanked the child after the mother had picked her up; and (2) defense first mentioned a reasonable discipline argument in closing even though defendant 'ha [d] contended th [e] entire time that he was just playing around.'. WebAug 24, 2024 · Commonwealth v. Dorvil, 472 Mass. 1, 13 (2015) (where there is some evidence that a parent used reasonable force in disciplining a minor child, the Commonwealth bears the burden of disproving at least one prong of the parental privilege), citing Commonwealth v. credit for other dependent rules